I’m not sure this picture even really needs a description… okay fine it is a Chocolate Chip Caramel Cookie Pie. Full of milk chocolate and caramel sauce it tastes like a freshly baked cookie that hasn’t had a chance to firm up yet. It is a warm and melty cookie inside of a pie crust covered in a delicious caramel sauce. Even if part of this pie somehow survives the first hour out of the oven, a quick 20 seconds in the microwave will bring it right back to life. You can’t go wrong with this cookie pie, it is easy to make and really impressive to serve!
A couple of days ago I was at a friend’s house as we were dealing with the fallout of the website move and we were planning a small get-together of friends. I wanted to make something fun and interesting since (as I am sure you can imagine) they have been getting delicious treats since the beginning of this blog. Then in a moment of nostalgia I remembered this recipe that I had made for my friends back home. It was so well received there I knew I had to make it. Sure enough, it was a hit, with both adults and kids alike.
If you would like to make your dough from scratch you can make the crust in the Apple Pie Slab Bars that I made. Just cut the proportions down to half. 🙂 That is a delicious pie crust that I make in the food processor in just a few minutes and then let rest in the fridge to keep the butter as cold as possible before rolling it out. 
You can insert a knife or toothpick but just be aware melted chocolate will get all over it. If the top looks browned and crisp after the timer goes off I would say you are good to go. 
Let it cool for at LEAST 15 minutes or it will not be set up at all and even though you do want it to be soft enough to eat with a spoon, it is just like any other pie, the filling will sort of spill out if you don’t give it a chance to cool for a short time first.
Go ahead, make this dessert. It will be a total crowd pleaser!
Ingredients
- 1 unbaked 9-inch pie shell
- 2 large eggs
- 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup granulated sugar
- 1/2 cup packed brown sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 stick butter , softened
- 1 cup milk chocolate chips
- 1 cup milk chocolate caramel chips
- 1/2 cup caramel sauce
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 325° F.
- Beat the eggs in large mixer bowl on high speed until foamy.
- Add in the flour, brown sugar, white sugar and vanilla.
- Beat in butter until combined.
- Stir in both kinds of chocolate chips.
- Put mixture into pie shell and even the mixture out in the shell
- Bake for 60 minutes.
- You can insert a knife or toothpick but just be aware melted chocolate will get all over it.
- If the top looks browned and crisp after the timer goes off I would say you are good to go.
- Warm caramel sauce for 15 seconds in the microwave before pouring over pie slices.
- Optional, serve with ice cream or whipped cream.
Notes
Nutrition
Want to save this recipe? Create a free account to easily save your favorite recipes
Just like the cookie dough, this pie can be made in any flavors. The original called for chocolate chips and chopped nuts. I subbed the nuts for more chocolate chips with caramel filling and topped it with more caramel sauce. I’ve also planned to make this with Oreo Cookies!
Wow, the photographs make me want to lick the screen!
Thanks! I feel like such a rookie when it comes to taking the photos, so that made my day!
That looks and sounds yummy! I would love to try making this.
Thanks!
Can we say chocolate heaven? Just a slice of that pie would make my day!
Haha, I was not shy about going whole hog on the decadence of this one 🙂
So this looks amazing! I will definitely have to be making this since my mouth is watering just looking at it.
Haha, yay I love getting that reaction!
This is amazing! I love this pie so much and was hoping you’d post it!
I was making cake batter ice cream today thinking I was going to dedicate to you in the post I wrote for it. Should’ve done that for this pie too!
I love both caramel and chocolate. And I love pie as well. So, why not have it all in one? I think this would be a great recipe for me!
Hope you enjoy it!
Yummy! Who could pass up a good pie? Especially one that contains both chocolate and caramel. It looks so wonderful!
Thank you!
Gooey and delicious! Please keep it away from me or I’ll eat it all up.
Oh yes, very gooey. It was hard to resist a third piece!
Oh my goodness, my mouth is watering! This chocolate caramel chip cookie pie look absolutely amazing!
Mission accomplished 😉
This looks like the perfect pie to make when company’s coming and I want to dazzle them with something besides blackberry or peach pie. I’ll make one for my brother next time he stops by. He ‘ll love it (and so will I).
Oh yes, surprise people with this pie and they will be on the look out for a lot more invitations!
Once again your food is making my mouth water! You take beautiful pictures and you make beautiful food! I always love seeing whats new on your site!
That is so sweet Toni! Thank you for the kind words, that made my day 🙂
Oh my tha looks amazing! Not sure I want to make it, I might be tempted to eat the whole thing.
Haha it is tempting. I only make it when I know I am taking it somewhere with other people!
This looks amazing. I know my girls would go gaga for this!
My oldest loved it too!
Desert is my favorite meal of the day. I’m pretty confident that I could eat this three times a day. Yum!
You and me both!
Chocolate and caramel–a little something for everyone. Or a lot of something as I plan to devour the entire thing in one sitting.
Hahaha. That’s awesome.
I have such a sweet tooth. I have a feeling I’d eat most of that in one sitting!
You wouldn’t be the first to do so O:)
How can this not be amazing? 🙂 But what torture. I so want a slice right now. 🙂
Haha me too! It is all gone now and I am sad.
You always seem to find such amazing recipes. This sounds like a great dessert for the next time we entertain.
Hope you enjoy it!
I must try this recipe. It looks so delicious. I have a BBQ coming up and this would be a perfect dessert.
Your guests will go ga-ga over it!
This looks so delicious and easy to make. I will have to try making this on the weekend. My family will love it.
Hope you love it!
I love anything with chocolate chips and my daughter loves caramel. This is a pie made just for the to of us.
Yes! A totally wonderful duo (just like a mom and her daughter!)!
What brilliant idea! So easy to make too, I love Tollhouse cookies, i bet this pie is amazing!
You’ll be shocked how ridiculously addicting the warm melty cookie is.
Whoa my goodness! Are you trying to kill us with sweetness and deliciousness? This is a HAVE TO MAKE!
I’m just trying to see how many people I can get to lick the screen, haha.
Wow, Gooey, chocolate-y and delicious!!!
Yup!
Looks like chocolatey goeyness goodness that I can’t wait to make for myself and try. Thanks so much for sharing the delish recipe.
You’re so welcome! Thank you for looking at the page!
WOW! That looks and sounds AMAZING!!! What an insanely delicious idea!
Aww how sweet, thank you!
Now this looks delicious! Did you save me some? Nothing is better than chocolate and caramel!!! Mmm!
Haha I’ll send some airmail 😉
Yep, I pinned it! And to my REAL dessert board too! Cuz I can only say, SAVE ME A PIECE!
Yay! Thanks so much for the pin! And to the real board!
I’m surprised how indulgent a dessert is so simple to make! We will be trying this this weekend for sure!
Awesome! I hope you love it!
This looks insanely delicious and would work so perfect with the tea I am drinking right now
Agreed! It worked great withy coffee this morning too!
Wow this looks like it would be so delicious. Chocolate chips and chopped nuts are a great combo!
Well, that’s it. You have won the unofficial Dawn’s Internet Award with this one. Anything with “chocolate caramel chip” in the name is automatically awesome.
Thank you, thank you… I would like to thank my dear sweet husband, for washing all the dishes and my markets for always being there for me to buy ingredients…
Oh my heavens. WHAT are you doing to me? This is amazing. I’m not only going to make this for my family, I’m going to try it and REALLY, REALLY enjoy it. Wow. That’s something else!
My goal is to make people drool, haha.
That looks so luscious – I want to eat it off the screen! Pinned.
Thanks so much for the pin!!
Holy deliciousness, Batman! I’ve got to give this a try. It looks Heavenly.
Hahaha, that is awesome.
This needs to stop. I can feel myself getting fatter just reading your posts! =D Seriously, though, thanks for another wonderful recipe. I’ve got quite a “to make” list building up thanks to you!
Haha, it has been pretty decadent recently!
Sabrina, you’ve used the magic 3 C’s – Chocolate Chip and Caramel.
You have now revealed the formula for EARTHLY HEAVEN!
These cookies look absolutely divine. Thanks for creating this! <3 FIVE STARS!
Hahaha, I tried to make it as decadent as I could.
Oh my goodness! Pie is my weakness. I love pie!. This recipe looks delicious and I bet I can make it gluten-free too!
Me too I am a sucker for pie!
This looks so yummy. I need to make this and serve it warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
oh yes, ice cream would be divine on this to play off the warm melty cookie goodness!
I am drooling over here. That looks ah-mazing.
Thanks!