Cookies
Not sure where to start? Try our two FAN FAVORITES first, these were voted on by over 150,000 email subscribers as their favorites: Oreo Chunk Cookies and amazing Award Winning Gingerbread Cookies.
Cookies of all kinds from cookie sandwiches, frosted cookies, shaped cookies, sliced cookies and more, there’s every cookie your Christmas baking exchange could ever desire!
You can make them as a treat for lunch, an easy after school snack, gifts for your neighbors or for the ultimate Christmas Cookie Exchange! Be sure to check out the Staff favorites on the site: Chocolate Chip Cookies, No Bake Cookies, Peanut Butter Blossoms and my personal favorite Hershey’s Kiss Cookies.
If you need tips and tricks for the best cookies be sure to read through the information above each recipe where we share best practices for each recipe.
Our Most Popular Cookies
Fall Favorite Cookies
All Cookies
Dark Chocolate Orange Biscotti
Easy, crumbly biscotti with orange zest and dark chocolate!
DoubleTree Chocolate Cookies (Copycat)
Amazingly buttery and gooey, just like DoubleTree Cookies!
Salted Double Chocolate Shortbread Cookies
Crumbly, buttery, chocolatey cookie with a little sea salt!
Italian Sprinkle Cookies
Soft, sweet, simple cookies topped with glaze and colorful sprinkles!
Snickerdoodle Chip Cookies
Chewy cinnamon cookies with melty, sweet white chocolate chips throughout!
Christmas Cookies
Simple buttery and chewy cookies loaded with festive M&Ms, peppermint, and sprinkles!
Christmas Pinwheel Cookies
Bright and happy Christmas cookies flavored with peppermint for the perfect holiday treat!
